Become What You Are (1993)

The Juliana Hatfield Three

Cover artwork for Become What You Are (1993)

Track list

  1. Supermodel
  2. My Sister
  3. This Is The Sound
  4. For The Birds
  5. Mabel
  6. A Dame With A Rod
  7. Addicted
  8. Feelin' Massachusetts
  9. Spin The Bottle
  10. President Garfield
  11. Little Pieces
  12. I Got No Idols

The biggest selling album of Juliana's career.

Released with commercial appeal rising following the critical success of Hey Babe and her association with the Lemnonheads, this was the most anticipated JH release to date. There are many sublime moments (Feelin’ Massachusetts, This Is The Sound) and it closes with stronger songs including the PJ Harvey influenced Spin The Bottle. Final track I Got No Idols remains one of Juliana’s classics.

A record which remains many fans' favourite album, not least as it was the record that introduced them to Juliana.

Personnel

Juliana Hatfield – guitar, vocals
Dean Fisher – bass
Todd Philips – drums
Denny Fongheiser – percussion
Peter Holsapple – keyboards

Retrospectives

Juliana, writing for a career retrospective article in Uncut Magazine, published in February 2026:

I wanted to distinguish it from Hey Babe, so I thought that by having a slightly different band name, maybe I could get more people to pay attention. Dean [Fisher]. the bass player, was someone that I grew up with in Duxbury, Massachusetts. And then Todd Phillips, the drummer, I had known for a few years. The most important thing was I needed to work with people I feel comfortable with. I don't necessarily go looking for the greatest players. I want them to be good, but it's more important that there's a rapport and that we like each other.

I was trying to get out of my emotional distress and look further outside of myself and write about what I was seeing. It's not as focused on unrequited love and depression - it's kinda all over the place in a cool way. "Mabel" is about a character in a John Cassavetes movie that I love, "My Sister" is about an imaginary sister, "A Dame With A Rod" is about killing a rapist... That's very dark, for sure. And in "Supermodel" it's a little unclear whether I'm criticising or I'm in solidarity with the supermodels. I was exploring conflicts in my own mind about image. I'm sure there were people at my record label who wanted me to show more skin and to exploit my own good looks. I was uncomfortable with that, and I was thinking, 'Why do women play into that?" And "A Dame With A Rod" is my feminism, my anger coming out.

I remember being in a hotel room in San Francisco. At that time, Guns N' Roses" "November Rain" was in heavy rotation on MTV - this really dramatic, elaborate video. Then my video came on and it was kind of a mindfuck, because I never thought of myself as a very commercial artist. I didn't have my image together - I didn't think about image. So it's like. 'How did this happen?' The song doesn't even have a chorus. But at the same time. it was thrilling. To know that your music's being heard by other people is a wonderful feeling.

Reviews

Select Magazine - September 1993
Select Magazine - September 1993

Show Select review transcriptHide Select review transcript

Juliana Hatfield — Become What You Are

Select, September 1993

Ev'ry knows she's miserable now.

JULIANA HATFIELD — Become What You Are — EAST WEST

When the folks at Barbie start designing their autumn collection of slacker grrrl clothing ("She cooks! She cleans! She kind of, well, mooches about a lot!") it's hard to think of a more perfect role model than Juliana Hatfield. As founding member of Boston band Blake Babies, occasional Lemonhead and all-round underachiever, her place in the Who's Who Of Grunge is already assured.

Following last year's solo debut, 'Hey Babe', which showed considerable promise, Become What You Are takes that promise and shoves it where the sun never shines. Maybe it's the new band (Dean Fisher on bass and Todd Philips, ex-Bullet Lavolta, on drums). Or even the new producer Scott Litt (former REM helmsman). Christ, maybe it's the new age of Aquarius, but for whatever reason Hatfield has come up with one of the few genuine play-it-so-loud-the-cops-come-round-and-then-make-them-listen-to-it albums of the year.

You want proof? Pick a track. Any track. The first one? Good call, because 'Supermodel' is a fair indication of what lurks ahead. Unobtrusive Litt production, a nailed down rhythm section, big, big guitars, plus that clear as a bell, high octave voice. And the lyrics? Hatfield does not waste the opportunity. Let's just say that the words "ass" and "trash" are linked in a manner guaranteed to have all concerned struck off Claudia's Christmas card list.

'My Sister', on the other hand, is a different cauldron of boiling angst altogether. While the whole album is suffused with a jarring combination of light, chartbound melodies and dark, introspective lyrics this is never more obvious than here. Leaving the band to churn out great wodges of bubblegum rock, Hatfield gets stuck in: "She's got a wall around her nobody can climb/She lets her ladder down for those who really shine." This is The Bangles with lyrics by Brian de Palma in a particularly psychotic mood. They even manage to namecheck the Violent Femmes without looking like complete idiots. Now that, ladies and gentlemen, really does take some doing.

Although the album occasionally edges towards Hole/Babes territory, with 'Addicted' or 'A Dame With A Rod' ("I got a gun/And no mercy for scum!") there's little doubting Hatfield's firm grip on tune heaven. Whether getting all elliptical on 'President Garfield' or just hanging with the guys for 'Spin The Bottle', the singer ensures that the pop machine keeps juddering on. And on.

Inevitably, it isn't all roses. Anyone irritated previously by Hatfield's fascination with everything child-like, for example, will find plenty to moan about here. 'For The Birds', in particular, features lyrics that would seem naive to a three-year-old wearing rose-tinted spectacles and beer goggles. There is also a lingering suspicion that the otherwise excellent 'Mabel' is named thus simply because it rhymes with "table". But these are the smallest of niggles whose very existence is wiped out by, say, the lolloping guitar solo in the middle of 'Feelin' Massachusetts'.

Love, hate and really loud guitars. Sometimes the oldest recipes are still the best. ■

Clark Collis

NME 1993
NME 1993

Show NME review transcriptHide NME review transcript

Juliana Hatfield — Become What You Are

NME, 1993

JULIANA HATFIELD — Become What You Are (east west/All formats)

HERE IS the legend of Juliana Hatfield.

She is 18, max—16 or 17 at a guess. Her parents are doctors or college lecturers; and though she'll gather round that month's Sassy with the others, party it up and smooch with the boys—she's also prone to run away into solitude in the corner of the local diner, where she hides from the tittle-tattle of teenage life.

While she's there, her friends will deride her for being a weirdo, knowing full well that she'll return to the fold in a day or two. She'll reach in her duffel bag for a copy of The Bell Jar or The Trial—and then write dark, plainly-worded poems in her exercise book; poems about finding a dying bird on the sidewalk, or about the guy she's lusted over precisely because he's going steady with another one of the gang, or about how living in smalltown Massachusetts is a mind-numbing business that makes her want to get out, pretty sharpish.

When she feels like it, she'll maybe phone up her friend Evan. No-one's sure if they're going out or not, or whether anything's ever happened between them. Anyway, the pair of them will go over to his parents' place and play each other their songs and tell each other that they're awesome. Then Mrs Dando will bring them cookies and milk and send Juliana home to her books and her poems and her solitude.

Such is her idealised myth—complicated by the fact that she's really in her mid-20s, and Evan's a bit older still—but there in the minds of her fans nonetheless. Why? Oh, just the fact that everything on last year's Dando-assisted (and brilliant) 'Hey Babe' debut had an unmistakable teenage ambience, on account of her bubblegum melodies and words, her cracked, plaintive coo-ing, and the likes of 'Everybody Loves Me But You' and 'Ugly' and 'Nirvana', which all dealt with mental states usually associated with the period in which your hormones go a bit awry.

There are streaks of Biactol, chocolate and illicit beer all over Become What You Are, too. Strangely, Juliana's lyrics seem to have become even more youthful: she's more keen than ever on predictable, blatant rhyming ("dying/ lying/ crying", "night/ light/ alright", "Mabel/ able/ table" etc. etc.), that makes her words sound like they've been scrawled under desks on scraps of file paper; and she's only heightened the teenage vibes by once again writing a clutch of songs about specifically adolescent experiences.

'My Sister' is all about sibling ambivalence: one minute Juliana's snarling, singing "I hate my sister, she's such a bitch", the next she's staring across the dining table, pleasantly awestruck, opining that "I love my sister, she's the best". 'Addicted' seems to deal with bulimia; about how the narrator can't help "digging up what I put away"; so much so that her body is "a broken, empty shell". She ends up singing "I don't want to die," and letting out strangulated vomit noises.

There's more: a straight-laced teenage lust song titled—no kidding—'Spin The Bottle'; 'Feelin' Massachusetts', a boredom anthem that's the East Coast's answer to 'Everyday Is Like Sunday'; and 'For The Birds', in which Juliana goes downtown, to, er, hang around, and finds a dying sparrow lying on (go on, lass! go on!) the ground: which is either a heartbreakingly unpretentious vignette or a dashed-off, squirm-prompting bit of primary school poetry from someone who really should know better. Such is the filmic spell cast by this record—it's like a teenage trauma movie shot solely from one person's perspective—that I'm forced to go for the former. Just.

Of course, some of Become What You Are—its twin peaks, in fact—deviate slightly from all this. 'Supermodel' is sung from the point of view of a hapless soul whose other half is "famous for nothing at all", so it takes a pop at the automatons on the catwalk and their manipulative overlords, while infusing the whole thing with a tragic sense of the dehumanising effects of it all. And 'A Dame With A Rod'—which is a pearler—finds Juliana gunning down a sex killer, standing over his corpse with a smoking piece, yelling "I'm a heroine/ He tried to do her in/ I gave it back to him/ He'll never do it again..."

And the music? Breezy garage-pop, on the whole; stuff that couples sass and suss with a melodic simplicity that makes large chunks of this record sound like The Ronettes having a crack at blue-eyed American college rock. Unfortunately, parts of Become What You Are are missing both the rough edges and the instant infectiousness of much of 'Hey Babe', giving 'This Is The Sound', 'President Garfield' and 'Little Pieces' an unwelcome Hatfield-by-numbers aura.

That blemish, and the annoyance caused by some of those lyrics, make Become What You Are—in the light of 'Hey Babe'—a little disappointing. But when Juliana's cooing in that fractured, airy voice; when the guitars are coasting around; when you're being both thrilled and disquieted... well, you're in that film, sitting in the corner of the diner, peering into her exercise book and asking if you can borrow one of her books. It's still a cool place to be. (7)

John Harris

Q 1993
Q 1993

Show Q review transcriptHide Q review transcript

Coltish

Q, 1993

Tired of Riot Grrrl? Don’t know what Riot Grrrl is? Try Juliana Hatfield.

JULIANA HATFIELD THREE
Become What You Are
EAST WEST 7567 9422

As far as “alternative” rock goes, the balance of payments with our American cousins has been looking distinctly unhealthy of late. Imports have flooded through our ports and airports from both old favourites like Neil Young and new lines such as Smashing Pumpkins and Alice In Chains. In truth, of course, many of these US exports have been as appetising as the McDonald’s Pizza but some have been genuinely welcome new finds. Evan Dando of The Lemonheads is one. His friend Juliana Hatfield is another.

Hatfield and Dando were a literal as well as metaphorical couple for some time and, though now “just good friends”, their songs share a particular perspective. Both combine a love of frazzled electric noise with an ear for a shapely melody. Also, both exude quirkily attractive personalities through their music in happy contrast to the belligerent dumbness of many grunge folk.

As a student at the Berklee [sic] College Of Music, Hatfield founded the cult trio, Blake Babies, mainstays of the same Boston scene from which the aforesaid Lemonheads and Dinosaur Jr emerged. Over the Blake Babies’ four late-80s albums, Hatfield honed her gift for left-field pop/rock that was to inform last year’s solo debut Hey Babe. Delightful though it was, Become What You Are represents a considerable progression. Personable, tuneful vignettes remain, as does a coltish exuberance but the architecture reveals strange details. Songs with frankly queer plots, weird wordless semi-hooks and pockets of shuddering turbulence found at the heart of the calmest pop songs.

Ostensibly, Supermodel is an unsisterly attack on “The world’s highest-paid piece of ass/Famous for nothing at all,” sneers Hatfield, before confessing, “I wish she’d trade places with me”. Morally ambiguous and obliquely memorable, it’s in some ways the typical modern Hatfield song.

My Sister is a similar blend of the jaunty and the chilling, a toe-tapping but off-kilter record of sibling love and hate. For The Birds boasts an unfathomable allegorical plot about caring for injured sparrows or something, but more importantly, a delectable chorus. Unlike the horse-frightening shriek factor of Babe In Toyland Kat Bjelland or Hole’s Courtney Love, Hatfield sings in a slangy, girlish alto, strikingly placed alongside her own guitar and the bass and drums of Dean Fisher and Todd Philips respectively. Those left cold by PJ Harvey’s bodily functions and shouting may find much to love in these darkly cute songs, nearer to Raymond Carver than so-called Riot Grrrl. ★★★★

Stuart Maconie

Photo caption: Juliana Hatfield Three (from left): Todd Philips, Juliana Hatfield, Dean Fisher.

Lime Lizard - September 1993
Lime Lizard - September 1993

Show Lime Lizard review transcriptHide Lime Lizard review transcript

Juliana Hatfield — Become What You Are

Lime Lizard, September 1993

JULIANA HATFIELD — become what you are (eastwest)

Sunny pop for a sunny day? Life-affirming, tear-jerking, sweety sailing guitar fuzz that'll have you singing in the street? Touchingly naive classic songwriting in the vein of Sebadoh or Tsunami? Or? Or? God, I HATE this record!!

Ickle-gurlie nails down blackboard time! Gratingly ordinary, ordinary, ordinary! Sorry, I just don't get it. Juliana Hatfield's songs mean nothing to me, not as a music fan, not even, I have to say, as a woman. Perhaps it's because I'm a woman and not a fifteen year old check-shirted boy-grunger; because I (unfairly) expect more than the obvious, more than the tepid from my peers. Something affecting, not self-consciously 'unaffected'. Perhaps it's got something to do with the fact that I also get zilch out of the ridiculously over-rated songs of Juliana's male counterpart: surely the Brad Willis of indie-pop—yeurch (does this make Hatfield the whingeing brat Lucy Robinson? Double yeurch).

To specifics: 'Supermodel', the first song, underachieves spectacularly given the vituperation that could be spent on the phenomenon in question. Even Rupaul's camped-up techno catwalk strut of the same name treats the subject with more wit and style; Voodoo Queens would eat her for breakfast. She seems to be complaining in a jolly sort of way about supermodels being overpaid ('$5,000 dollars a day/ Is what my baby gets /For her pretty face'); hey, that'll have Cindy quaking in her golden sandals. Nevermind that these girls are complicit cogs in an elitist industry that defines oppressively unattainable (and unhealthy) ideals of beauty; ideals that devalue the physical appearance of 90% of us mere mortals.

In the pre-pubescent cutesy world of Become What You Are, Hatfield splutters fetchingly on an unaccustomed cigarette and grieves over dying birds ('I don't care for boys and girls/ I'd rather hang around with birds/ Humans only wreck the world'); she goes to Violent Femmes gigs and watches all them quirky, kooky people down on the street; her big sister's the coolest girl in the world and Juliana's a mischievous little scamp. Is she in terminal denial?

Really, I don't mind cuteness in its place; I love Bjork's kittenish little whoops, for example. But all the 'yeah yeah's and 'ah-ah-ah's in the world aren't going to turn this into instant 'classic pop'; the unremitting bounciness of the indie guitars and the banality of the lyrics are not in the slightest bit endearing. It is possible to de-familiarise the everyday, re-present it in an original and moving way, so that the simplest things (walking down the street, children's games, birds) become breathtakingly imbued with significance. Juliana Hatfield is, however, simply twee. Everybody loves you but me.

Lucy Cage

Video

Play: Juliana Hatfield - A Dame With A Rod - Raw Soup 1993
Watch on YouTube
Play: Juliana Hatfield - My Sister (1993)
Watch on YouTube
Play: The Juliana Hatfield Three - Spin the Bottle (music video) (HQ)
Watch on YouTube
Play: Juliana Hatfield @ Rhino Records, Westwood, CA (8/10/93)
Watch on YouTube
Play: Juliana Hatfield Three - My Sister - Acoustic & interviewed London 1993
Watch on YouTube
Play: Juliana Hatfield Three 1993 12 20 Live 2 tracks @ The Beat
Watch on YouTube

About the above video:

Press Ad

Image

Artwork

Image

Image

Image

Alternate Artwork

In August 2012 during a PledgeMusic funding campaign for her then upcoming self titled covers album, Juliana posted hitherto unseen images from 1993 of proposed / alternate artwork for Become What You Are.

The first is a photograph of her brother.

Image

Image

Image

2020 Acoustic Performance

Image

On December 19, 2020, Juliana performed the album in full (twice!) in a solo acoustic livestream from Q Division Studios in Somerville, MA. This was available on a pay as you want basis, free to watch on YouTube.

The stream was available for a couple of weeks over the following holiday period but removed as planned in January 2021.

2023 Vinyl Reissue

Image

American Laundromat Records, in October 2022:

We are stoked to reissue Become What You Are on vinyl to celebrate its 30th Anniversary. This exclusive reissue is limited to 2,500 units worldwide.

Reissue artwork prepared by Aaron Tanner at Melodic Virtue from the original art. Our good friend Sean Glonek at SRG studios handled remastering, Levi Seitz cut metal, and the fine folks at Furnace pressed the vinyl. It looks and sounds amazing! We are very proud of this reissue and hope you enjoy it.

There were 3 variants with a further yellow splatter variant available from indie stores. This reissue was released in January 2023.

www.alr-music.com/collections/catalog/products/jh3-become-what-you-are